Your home for rare & advanced Kung Fu

Our Award Winning Instructional Format:

Extensive history of the material, overviews including fast & slo-mos, instructional segments from multiple angles, AND fighting techniques for each segment!

  • Log in
  • Create an account
  • Check out
Cart:0item(s)
Green Dragon Kung Fu Productions, LLC
Green Dragon Kung Fu Productions, LLC Traditional Kung-Fu

Honoring

Sifu Allen

  • Home
  • Empty Hand
    • Empty Hand: 1. Beginners Level

      • Nine Power Development Exercises: by ...
      • Shaolin 5 Animals Health & Power Prog...
      • One Hour Workout with Green Dragon (f...
      • See all Empty Hand: 1. Beginners Level

      Empty Hand: 2. Intermediate Level

      • Small Fire Dragon from Northern White...
      • Snake Exercise Sets: Fukien and 5-Ani...
      • Master's Class: Fundamentals of Empty...
      • See all Empty Hand: 2. Intermediate Level

      Empty Hand: 3. Advanced Level

      • Teet Lo Han Chin Ch'uan from Iron Bud...
      • Goun Gee Kuen from Hung Style
      • Continuous Palms: Pai Lien Chien Lien...
      • See all Empty Hand: 3. Advanced Level

      Empty Hand: 4. Expert Level

      • Mook Joong (Wooden Dummy) or Comparab...
      • White Crane of Wu Mei (Pai Hao Fan Tu...
      • Night Leopard Strikes from the Forest...
      • See all Empty Hand: 4. Expert Level

      White Lotus Combined System (Ancient Style) Empty Hand & Weapons

      • Continuous Palms: Pai Lien Chien Lien...
      • Iron Crutches: (Shuang T'eh Kuai Chan...
      • Baton / Cane: Traveler's Cane of Whit...
      • See all White Lotus Combined System (Ancient Style) Empty Hand & Weapons

      Strength Programs

      • Nine Power Development Exercises: by ...
      • One South Fist (I Nan Kuen) from Choy...
      • No Lick Kuen (from Hung Style)/Sup Ge...
      • See all White Lotus Combined System (Ancient Style) Empty Hand & Weapons

      Allen Sifu: Instruction/Presentations

      • Teet Lo Han Chin Ch'uan from Iron Bud...
      • Mook Joong (Wooden Dummy) or Comparab...
      • Question and Answer Session 1A (FREE!...
      • See all White Lotus Combined System (Ancient Style) Empty Hand & Weapons

      Training Packs

      • Premier Power/Strength Pack (Includes...
      • Speed Training Pack (25% savings!)
      • Sifu Allen's Personal Favorites
      • See all Training Packs
  • Weapons Forms
    • Weapons: 1. Beginner's Level

      • Weighted/Heavy Staff (Hu Dip Chung Kw...
      • See all Weapons: 1. Beginner's Level

      Weapons: 2. Intermediate Level

      • Master's Class: Fundamentals of the S...
      • Iron Crutches: (Shuang T'eh Kuai Chan...
      • Master's Class: Fundamentals of the K...
      • See all Weapons: 2. Intermediate Level

      Weapons: 3. Advanced Level

      • Straight Sword: Plum Blossom Upon the...
      • Kwan Sword: Kwan's Knife Steals the W...
      • Staff (Bo): Combined Methods Staff (B...
      • See all Weapons: 3. Advanced Level

      Weapons: 4. Expert Level

      • Baton / Cane: Traveler's Cane of Whit...
      • Broadsword / Saber (Two or Double Sab...
      • Knife / Double Daggers: Double Headed...
      • See all Weapons: 4. Expert Level

      • See all
  • Free Training
    • Stretching & Flexibility

      Strength Building

      Drills

      Fighting Techniques

      Kung-Fu Workouts

      Weapons Basics

      Questions & Answers

      Vintage

  • Forms Index
  • BlogSifu Allen Says...
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

On Promotion II

  • Home
  • Empty Hand
    • Empty Hand: 1. Beginners Level
      • Nine Power Development Exercises...
      • Shaolin 5 Animals Health & Power...
      • One Hour Workout with Green Drag...
      • Stance Programs from 3 Different...
      • No Lick Kuen (from Hung Style)/S...
      • One South Fist (I Nan Kuen) from...
      • Teet Sao or T'ieh Shou (AKA: Iro...
    • Empty Hand: 2. Intermediate Level
      • Small Fire Dragon from Northern ...
      • Snake Exercise Sets: Fukien and ...
      • Master's Class: Fundamentals of ...
      • White Ape Comes Out of the Cave ...
      • White Eyebrow Small Cross (Bak M...
      • White Eyebrow Tiger Hand (Bak Me...
      • Tang Lang Mantis: Tsai Chang Ch'...
    • Empty Hand: 3. Advanced Level
      • Teet Lo Han Chin Ch'uan from Iro...
      • Goun Gee Kuen from Hung Style
      • Continuous Palms: Pai Lien Chien...
      • Tams: Tom Toi (Tam Tui) from Sou...
      • White Headed Snake Strikes Out f...
      • Northern White Dragon (Meng Lung...
      • Tiger/Leopard/Snake/Crane/Dragon...
    • Empty Hand: 4. Expert Level
      • Mook Joong (Wooden Dummy) or Com...
      • White Crane of Wu Mei (Pai Hao F...
      • Night Leopard Strikes from the F...
      • Pa Chi: Armor and Shield Piercin...
      • 8 Drunken Immortals Chung-Li Cha...
      • A Brass Hammer on an Iron Anvil ...
    • White Lotus Combined System (Ancient Style) Empty Hand & Weapons
      • Continuous Palms: Pai Lien Chien...
      • Iron Crutches: (Shuang T'eh Kuai...
      • Baton / Cane: Traveler's Cane of...
      • Knife: Cuts Like Lightning Knife...
      • Staff (Bo): Warriors 3/4 Staff (...
      • Fan: (K'ao Pu Chu Hua Shan) from...
      • Baton: Changing Hands Baton (Kai...
    • Strength Programs
      • Nine Power Development Exercises...
      • One South Fist (I Nan Kuen) from...
      • No Lick Kuen (from Hung Style)/S...
      • Teet Lo Han Chin Ch'uan from Iro...
      • Goun Gee Kuen from Hung Style
      • Stone Warrior (Instruction by Si...
      • Premier Power/Strength Pack (Inc...
    • Allen Sifu: Instruction/Presentations
      • Teet Lo Han Chin Ch'uan from Iro...
      • Mook Joong (Wooden Dummy) or Com...
      • Question and Answer Session 1A (...
      • Lo Han Shou of Tamo
      • Tai Chi Ch'uan from Yang Family ...
      • Chi Kung (chi gong, QiGong) Mast...
      • Pa Kua Chang or Bagua Zhang (Rar...
  • Weapons Forms
    • Weapons: 1. Beginner's Level
      • Weighted/Heavy Staff (Hu Dip Chu...
    • Weapons: 2. Intermediate Level
      • Master's Class: Fundamentals of ...
      • Iron Crutches: (Shuang T'eh Kuai...
      • Master's Class: Fundamentals of ...
      • Master's Class: Fundamentals of ...
      • Knife: Cuts Like Lightning Knife...
      • Broadsword/Saber (Dao): Hong Lon...
      • Fan: (K'ao Pu Chu Hua Shan) from...
    • Weapons: 3. Advanced Level
      • Straight Sword: Plum Blossom Upo...
      • Kwan Sword: Kwan's Knife Steals ...
      • Staff (Bo): Combined Methods Sta...
      • Spear (Double Headed): Pei Fang ...
      • Staff (Bo): Warriors 3/4 Staff (...
      • Tri-Sectional Staff: Pai Fo Chun...
      • Baton: Changing Hands Baton (Kai...
    • Weapons: 4. Expert Level
      • Baton / Cane: Traveler's Cane of...
      • Broadsword / Saber (Two or Doubl...
      • Knife / Double Daggers: Double H...
      • Wind and Fire Wheels: Feng Huo F...
      • Iron Rulers Seek the Dragon (Shu...
      • Butterfly Knives Drive the Tiger...
      • Iron Rulers Seek the Tiger (Shua...
  • Free Training
  • Index of Forms
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • From The Sifu
  • On Promotion II

From The Sifu

On Promotion II
Posted on: Jul 28

IMG_1090The following are parts II & III of an article from Sifu in reference to his views on standards for promotion and/or standards for more equitable judging in tournament competition.

 

THE DIVERSITY OF THE CHINESE MARTIAL ARTS AS CONTRASTED WITH THE COMMONALITIES INHERENT IN THE KARATE STYLES

Rather than treating Categories II & III separately, it became increasingly clear with development that it would be more expedient to let them unfold together.

When your author began his 56 year association with the Oriental Martial Arts in 1957, it started with 6+ years and a Black Belt in Shotokan, the earliest and largest of the Japanese karate styles–now over 20 in number (some sources say over 70).  Shotokan is the parent style of the founding father of Japanese karate, Gichin Funakoshi, and was established in 1917 – a history obviously less than 100 years old in sharp contrast to the evolution of kung-fu which could exceed 3,500 years in formulation!  Despite books written to the contrary, kung-fu did NOT originate at the Shaolin Monastery in Honan Province in N. China coincident with the arrival of an Indian Kshatriya class Chan Buddhist monk named Bodhidarma (circa 481-557 A.D.) and known to the Chinese as Pu-Ti-Ta-Mo (short to Tamo/Damo, etc.).  In point of fact, rudimentary elements of kung-fu may well exceed 35 centuries of continual development as its oldest system, Shuai Chiao, has grappling techniques depicted on turtle shells that early!

The stark contrast in the time of origination between the Chinese systems and that of the karate styles accounts for both the great quantity and variety differential that exists, as well as the prominent and unusual ‘stylizations’ so characteristic of only kung-fu–the latter due in large measure to basing the design of hundreds of fighting forms on a wide cross-section of animal life (so that mantis looks nothing like crane, snake looks nothing like tiger, monkey looks nothing like dragon, etc.–alone a facet which accounts for manifold distinctions in the components [basics] of the Art).

The actual scope of the vast difference between the manifold dissimilarities intrinsic to kung-fu as opposed to the commonalities evident in the karate styles is hard to envision until either long term training has been received or an extensive investigation is conducted to form the concept from study.  The quantitative issues are easy to perceive – i.e., every style of karate can tabulate the number of katas or exercise programs it has available for teaching, whereas the larger kung-fu systems would find this problematic at best, totally impossible at worst!  All of the karate styles put together probably don’t have more than 150-200 original katas between them; conversely, kung-fu’s Choy Li Fut, for example, has that many forms by itself, not to consider that the number of formal sets in the Chinese systems generally are literally innumerable – certainly, there are many thousands!

As a further representation of this, Shotokan has only 20-30 individual pieces of formal material in total, and even then chooses to emphasize the five katas in the Heian series. Despite this paucity of fighting forms, it still exceeds in number what is available for teaching in most other karate styles regardless of national association (Korea & Okinawa).  A typical case in point, Okinawan Isshin-Ryu, has fewer than 20 katas, but primarily focuses on 8 key empty hand sets and regards sufficient mastery of those as the main basis for promotion to Black Belt. Likewise, Korean Tae Kwon Do, while frequently considering ‘karate’ as a negative epithet, nevertheless shares the same mechanics and technique of the broad range of karate styles, and, like the latter, has a limited quantity of formal material despite claims to a much older historical heritage.

Before discussing qualitative differences, there are two quick ways to acquire a solid, working concept of the obvious commonalities indigenous to the entire world of karate: (1) Attend one or more major tournaments where multiple styles are represented – you won’t be able to identify one style from another without a scorecard!  (2) More convenient, there was a an excellent DVD produced in recent years called “Masters of the Martial Arts” which describes itself as “The most complete collection of historical footage of masters in the martial arts ever compiled.”  When it comes to the broad range of karate styles which is what it emphasizes (judo & aikido are included to a lesser extent), it lives up to the hype. Purposely not designed for instructional purposes, it is composed of snippets of varying lengths identifying and honoring (usually in performance) over 80 of the greatest masters in history, even including old film fragments of the legendary founders such as Gichin Funakoshi [Shotokan], Jigoro Kano [Judo], Morihei Ueshiba [Aikido], etc..  The DVD includes the highest ranked, most well known, and/or most widely publicized practitioners in Shotokan [Nishiyama, Nakayama, Okazaki, Kanazawa, et. al.], Wado-Ryu, Goju-Ryu, Shito-Ryu, Shorin-Ryu, Isshin-Ryu, etc..  If this comprehensive documentary is watched carefully, even an untrained eye can easily discern the overwhelming similarities; in fact, the resemblance is so close that only experienced students could perceive any nuances of difference.  Indicative of this, two frequently expressed remarks from kung-fu students analyzing the DVD are: “Why are they all doing the same thing?” and “Why don’t they perform any of their ‘advanced’ material?”  The answer to these has already been alluded to – i.e., the fighting styles that have no close Chinese association lack both the variety and complexity so characteristic of kung-fu.

← Previous post
Next post →

Collections

  • 2-Man Sets
  • Allen Sifu: Instruction/Presentations
  • Allen Sifu: Master's Series
  • Allen Sifu: Personally Instructs
  • Bok Mei Pai "White Eyebrow" Style
  • Chang Ch'uan "Emperor's Long Fist"
  • Choy Li Fut
  • Dragon Styles
  • Empty Hand: 1. Beginners Level
  • Empty Hand: 2. Intermediate Level
  • Empty Hand: 3. Advanced Level
  • Empty Hand: 4. Expert Level
  • Featured Forms
  • Honan/Henan Shaolin
  • Hsing I (Northern and Southern)
  • Hung Style
  • Internal Systems
  • Iron Buddha
  • Mantis
  • Monkey
  • Ng Ga Kuen (Southern Five Family style)
  • Northern Five Animals Shaolin
  • Novice Level
  • Plum Blossom Style
  • Self-Defense Focus: Fighting/Combat Skills and Strength
  • Shantung "Shandong" Shaolin
  • Southern Five Animal Shaolin
  • Strength Programs
  • Tams
  • Training Packs
  • Wanderer's Style (rare)
  • Weapons: 1. Beginner's Level
  • Weapons: 2. Intermediate Level
  • Weapons: 3. Advanced Level
  • Weapons: 4. Expert Level
  • Weapons: 5. Double or Twin (Advanced and Expert Level)
  • White Lotus Combined System (Ancient Style) Empty Hand & Weapons

Product Types

  • Unknown Type
  • Chinese Martial Arts
  • Chinese Martial Arts Instruction
  • Chinese Martial Arts weapons
  • Streaming and DVD

Best Sellers

Information

  • Search
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Index of Forms
  • Login To View Purchased Videos

Empty Hand

Weapons

  • Beginner's Weapons
  • Intermediate Weapons
  • Advanced Weapons
  • Highly Advanced Weapons

Traditional Kung-Fu

  • Green Dragon Kung Fu Productions, LLC
  • 1675 E. Main St., Suite 180, Kent, OH 44240
  • support@greendragonkungfu.com

FOLLOW US:

© 2025 Green Dragon Kung Fu Productions, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Shopify.

Product Added to Cart